| State | Top Holiday Candy | 2nd Place | 3rd Place |
| AK | Hershey Kisses | Candy Canes | Reese's Pieces |
| AL | Reindeer Corn | Candy Canes | Peppermint Bark |
| AR | Snickers | Starburst | Peppermint Bark |
| AZ | Reese's Cup Minis | Hershey Kisses | Skittles |
| CA | Peppermint Bark | Hershey Kisses | Reese's Cup Minis |
| CO | Candy Canes | Hershey Kisses | Reese's Pieces |
| CT | Starburst | Reindeer Corn | Candy Canes |
| DC | Snickers | Candy Canes | M&M's |
| DE | Reindeer Corn | Candy Canes | Hershey Kisses |
| FL | Skittles | Snickers | M&M's |
| GA | Snickers | Reindeer Corn | Candy Canes |
| HI | Starburst | Hershey Kisses | Reindeer Corn |
| IA | Peppermint Bark | Reese's Cup Minis | M&M's |
| ID | M&M's | Hershey Kisses | Chocolate Santas |
| IL | Hershey Kisses | Reese's Cup Minis | M&M's |
| IN | Reese's Cup Minis | Hershey Kisses | Candy Canes |
| KS | Peppermint Bark | Hershey Kisses | Candy Canes |
| KY | Peppermint Bark | M&M's | Candy Canes |
| LA | Candy Canes | Reindeer Corn | Pez |
| MA | Candy Canes | Hershey Kisses | Reese's Cup Minis |
| MD | Reese's Cup Minis | Candy Canes | Reese's Pieces |
| ME | Chocolate Santas | Hershey Kisses | Candy Canes |
| MI | Reindeer Corn | Reese's Cup Minis | Peppermint Bark |
| MN | Reese's Cup Minis | Hershey Kisses | Peppermint Bark |
| MO | Peppermint Bark | Hershey Kisses | Starburst |
| MS | Peppermint Bark | Candy Canes | Reindeer Corn |
| MT | Reese's Pieces | Reese's Cup Minis | Reindeer Corn |
| NC | Snickers | Reindeer Corn | Starburst |
| ND | Chocolate Santas | Reindeer Corn | Reese's Cup Minis |
| NE | Hershey Kisses | M&M's | Peppermint Bark |
| NH | Reindeer Corn | Candy Canes | Reese's Cup Minis |
| NJ | Reese's Cup Minis | Skittles | Pez |
| NM | Chocolate Santas | Pez | Candy Canes |
| NV | Peppermint Bark | Candy Canes | Starburst |
| NY | Candy Canes | Snickers | Reese's Cup Minis |
| OH | Hershey Kisses | Pez | Peppermint Bark |
| OK | Candy Canes | Reindeer Corn | Skittles |
| OR | Reese's Cup Minis | Candy Canes | Snickers |
| PA | Reese's Cup Minis | Candy Canes | Reindeer Corn |
| RI | Reindeer Corn | Peppermint Bark | M&M's |
| SC | M&M's | Peppermint Bark | Pez |
| SD | Chocolate Santas | Hershey Kisses | Reese's Cup Minis |
| TN | Peppermint Bark | Candy Canes | Starburst |
| TX | Peppermint Bark | Reese's Cup Minis | Candy Canes |
| UT | Hershey Kisses | Reindeer Corn | M&M's |
| VA | M&M's | Candy Canes | Reindeer Corn |
| VT | Snickers | Candy Canes | Reindeer Corn |
| WA | Reese's Cup Minis | Candy Canes | Skittles |
| WI | Peppermint Bark | Reindeer Corn | Starburst |
| WV | Peppermint Bark | Pez | Jolly Rancher |
| WY | Chocolate Santas | M&M's | Reese's Cup Minis |