These 16 Candy Brownie Recipes Will Change The Way You Make Brownies Forever

These 16 Candy Brownie Recipes Will Change The Way You Make Brownies Forever

We have something new to add to your list of favorite pairings: candy and brownies. We’re not referring to those packaged brownies with candy sprinkles on top (ahem, Cosmic Brownies). We’re talking rich, homemade brownies packed with your favorite type of candy bar.

We’re constantly discovering new ways of eating candy thanks to Pinterest (have you followed us yet?) and we think this might be our favorite to date. We can also credit Pinterest with teaching us things…like, before today, we had no idea that light-colored brownies made with brown sugar and flour are called “blondies.”

Listed below are 16 mouth-watering recipes for candy-filled brownies. Some of them are doctored box brownie recipes, and others are from scratch; so if you’re an impatient sweet tooth who’s short on time, don’t worry. There are tons of super easy recipes here, using all your favorite candy brands. And you can always substitute your favorite candy, of course.

If you’re more involved and like to take your time when it comes to baking, there are also plenty of from-scratch brownie recipes that you just might save in your confection arsenal for entertaining.

1. Milky Way Double Fudge Brownies

Aimee from Shugary Sweets combined chocolate mousse with creamy Milky Way bars to create this decadent brownie creation. The recipe calls for 3 layers: a brownie base, a chocolate mousse/Milky Way layer, and a milk chocolate topping.

Get the recipe here.

2. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Brownies

Heather from Livin’ The Pie Life made these peanut buttery brownies from scratch, using one of her go-to brownie recipes. She adds some salty, roasted peanuts and Reese’s peanut butter cups to create a moist, fudgy, sweet and salty confection.

Check out the full recipe here.

3. Snickers Brownie Bites

Brownie bites still qualify as brownies…they’re just bite-sized so that we all feel better about eating them. You can probably use this recipe to make full-sized brownies, as well. Just be sure you have some marshmallow fluff and some caramels handy.

Get more of the sweetness here.

4. Rolo Fudge Brownies

Rolo has to be one of the most underrated candies of all time. They’re silky, melty, and delicious without having too many ingredients. And, of course, they’re perfect for caramel chocolate brownies. Look at that picture, how could you not make this? Extra props to Shelly for adding that extra caramel topping as “Rolo glue.”

See more delicious photos and get the recipe here.

5. Butterfinger Brownies


These 16 Candy Brownie Recipes Will Change The Way You Make Brownies Forever

Credit: Recipe Girl

Blogger-chefs always have funny anecdotes when walking you through a recipe. Lori from Recipe Girl had a particularly amusing story behind these Butterfinger brownies; her kids are starting to ask uncomfortable questions as they enter their pre-teen years, and these brownies make it all feel better. With tons of crunchy Butterfingers, peanut butter, and chocolate, how could it not make everything better?

Get more of the recipe (and the funny musings) here.

6. Hershey’s Cream Cheese Swirled Brownies

These 16 Candy Brownie Recipes Will Change The Way You Make Brownies Forever

Credit: Doughmesstic

The melted Hershey’s bar topping on these cream cheese swirled brownies make us feel some type of way, what about you? Susan from Doughmesstic was inspired by a trip she was planning to Hershey, Pennsylvania, and decided to make a batch of these brownies in anticipation. She melts a full Hershey’s bar on top of the brownies. To die for.

Get the cream cheese-y recipe here.

7. Loaded Candy Bar Brownies

These loaded candy bar brownies would be a fantastic recipe for all of that leftover Halloween candy that your kids won’t get around to eating*. You can use any type of fun-size candy you choose, but we wouldn’t recommend mixing something like Jujubee’s with Milky Way bars. Just mix the candy with a boxed brownie mix and you’re good to go! Your kids will thank you when they take them to school…if there are any left.

Won’t get around to eating, as in, they would eat them, but you won’t let them get around to it.

Check out more at I Heart Naptime.

8. M&M Blonde Brownies

Aren’t blonde brownies technically called blondies? We don’t know, or care, because these blonde brownies look too amazing NOT to include in this list. All you need is a little flour, brown sugar, butter, and M&M’s and you’ve got 24 delicious blonde brownies ready to be ravaged.

Check out the blondie brownies here.

9. Bomb Brownies

These 16 Candy Brownie Recipes Will Change The Way You Make Brownies Forever

Credit: Lil Luna

We’re not sure how Lil Luna got the name, but these bomb brownies sound explosive: Butterfinger, Reese’s cups, and Cocoa Pebbles cereal! What could be better than that? We love the combination of crunchy cereal and gooey chocolate. The only remaining question: if you pour milk over these brownies, will it turn into chocolate milk?

Get the recipe at Lil Luna.

10. Baby Ruth Brownies

When you take a look at this recipe by Jesenia from The Latina Homemaker, you’ll assume that Baby Ruth bars — which are definitely named after Babe Ruth — were originally intended to be eaten inside of a brownie. With a homemade icing included in the recipe, you have no reason not to try this!

Get the full recipe at The Latina Homemaker.

11. Candy Cane Brownies

Who says candy canes are only edible during Christmas time? Turn the A/C down and the fireplace up and make your own Christmas in July with these chocolate mint brownies. Can’t find any candy canes at the store? Don’t worry, we always have candy canes in bulk!

Get your Christmas cheer on here.

12. “Crazy” Brownies

With an ingredient list that includes M&Ms, Reese’s peanut butter cups, and Rolo’s, we understand why they’re called “crazy” brownies: you’d have to be crazy not to try them! The final shot doesn’t even capture the decadence of this recipe, so check out the in-process photos for some extra indulgence.

Get the recipe here.

13. Kit-Kat Brownies

Once you check out this recipe, you REALLY won’t be able to get enough of that Kit Kat bar. We love the fact that you can see whole pieces of the candy bar inside the brownie. Sarah from Raining Hot Coupons makes it incredibly easy to enjoy Kit-Kat bars in a new way with this quick recipe. Just don’t overcook it!

Get the full recipe here.

14. Andes Mint Brownies

These 16 Candy Brownie Recipes Will Change The Way You Make Brownies Forever

Credit: Bakerette

Mint and chocolate go together like…mint and chocolate. If you love the power couple of the chocolate community, look no further than this recipe by Bakerette. It’s a 3-layer brownie that might be best served chilled.

Find out how the Bakerette did it here.

15. Reese’s Cheesecake Brownies

These 16 Candy Brownie Recipes Will Change The Way You Make Brownies Forever

Credit: Pip & Ebby

Don’t mistake these Reese’s cheesecake brownies for some run of the mill peanut butter and chocolate brownies; you’d be forgetting the key element: cheesecake. Combining any type of candy with cheesecake is always a win, in our books.

See more at Pip and Ebby.

16. Take 5 Brownies

These 16 Candy Brownie Recipes Will Change The Way You Make Brownies Forever

Credit: Noble Pig

Take 5 bars are hit or miss in the candy community; some people love them and others can’t stand them. If you’re a Take 5 lover, then this brownie recipe was made for you. It’s a box brownie mix “upgrade”, if you will, and if you’re into simple recipes you’ll probably never forget this one. Substitute the Take 5 bars for something else and share your experiences with us!

Check out the super-easy recipe here.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

12 + seventeen =

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.