Skip to content
Free Shipping On Orders $100+
SHOP NOW
Best Sellers
By Candy Type
By Candy Type
Individually Wrapped Candy
Gummy Candy
Jelly Beans
Mints & Peppermint Candy
Old-Fashioned Candy
Sour Candy
Salt Water Taffy
Chocolate Candy
Rock Candy
Unwrapped & Loose Candy
Gum & Bubblegum Candy
Lollipops & Suckers
View all Candy Types
By Color
By Color
Blue Candy
Pink Candy
White Candy
Black Candy
Red Candy
Orange Candy
Green Candy
Yellow Candy
Gold Candy
Silver Candy
Purple Candy
Assorted Colors Candy
View all Colors
By Brand
By Brand
Haribo Candy
Hershey's Candy
Jelly Belly
Jolly Rancher
M&M's
Skittles Candy
Peelerz
PEZ Candy
Taffy Town
Tootsie Candy
Sixlets Candy
Whirly Pops
View all by Brand Name
By Occasion
By Occasion
4th of July Candy
Summer & Beach Candy
Wedding Candy
Halloween Candy
Christmas Candy
New Year's Candy
Valentine's Day Candy
Back to School Candy
Thanksgiving & Autumn
Easter Candy
Hanukkah Candy
Party Favors & Gifts Candy
View all Occasions & Holidays
By Flavor
By Flavor
Assorted Fruit Candy
Apple Candy
Banana Candy
Bean Boozled
Coffee & Espresso Candy
Cookies & Cookie Dough Candy
Cherry Candy
Grape Candy
Honey Candy
Lemon Candy
Orange Flavored Candy
Strawberry Candy
Raspberry & Blue Raspberry
Root Beer & Soda Pop
Tropical Fruit Candy
Watermelon Candy
View all Flavors
Candy Buffets
Account
Contact Us
Customer Reviews
Blog
FAQs
Shop All Candy
Free Shipping on orders $100+
Log in
Log in
Cart
Best Sellers
By Candy Type
Individually Wrapped Candy
Gummy Candy
Jelly Beans
Mints & Peppermint Candy
Old-Fashioned Candy
Sour Candy
Salt Water Taffy
Chocolate Candy
Rock Candy
Unwrapped & Loose Candy
Gum & Bubblegum Candy
Lollipops & Suckers
View all Candy Types
By Color
Blue Candy
Pink Candy
White Candy
Black Candy
Red Candy
Orange Candy
Green Candy
Yellow Candy
Gold Candy
Silver Candy
Purple Candy
Assorted Colors Candy
View all Colors
By Brand
Haribo Candy
Hershey's Candy
Jelly Belly
Jolly Rancher
M&M's
Skittles Candy
Peelerz
PEZ Candy
Taffy Town
Tootsie Candy
Sixlets Candy
Whirly Pops
View all by Brand Name
By Occasion
4th of July Candy
Summer & Beach Candy
Wedding Candy
Halloween Candy
Christmas Candy
New Year's Candy
Valentine's Day Candy
Back to School Candy
Thanksgiving & Autumn
Easter Candy
Hanukkah Candy
Party Favors & Gifts Candy
View all Occasions & Holidays
By Flavor
Assorted Fruit Candy
Apple Candy
Banana Candy
Bean Boozled
Coffee & Espresso Candy
Cookies & Cookie Dough Candy
Cherry Candy
Grape Candy
Honey Candy
Lemon Candy
Orange Flavored Candy
Strawberry Candy
Raspberry & Blue Raspberry
Root Beer & Soda Pop
Tropical Fruit Candy
Watermelon Candy
View all Flavors
Candy Buffets
FAQS
Shop All Candy
Item added to your cart
Check out
Continue shopping
i-love-ny-milk-chocolate-bar-24ct
Popular Categories
Chocolate Coins & Coin Candy
Chocolate Coins & Coin Candy
Rock Candy
Rock Candy
Salt Water Taffy
Salt Water Taffy
Sour Candy
Sour Candy
Other Brands You Might Like
AirHeads
AirHeads
Skittles Candy
Skittles Candy
Starburst Candy
Starburst Candy
Warheads
Warheads
Tootsie Candy
Tootsie Candy
M&M's
M&M's
Taffy Town
Taffy Town
Jelly Belly
Jelly Belly
Twix Bars
Twix Bars
Collection:
i-love-ny-milk-chocolate-bar-24ct
Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.
